Modi 2.0 Cabinet

Vishal Chauhan, 31/05/2019
Modi 2.0 Cabinet

Prime Minister Narendra Modi's 2.0 council of ministers is the handiwork of a pragmatic politician. Like the adjective, drawn from the Greek word 'pragma' or deed, it describes a worldview of "doing what works best" – Modi believes in pursuing nothing but the path to success.

This may often, as in his case, be at variance with the words he uses to convey that he unwavering follows the course of principles. But the vocabulary he draws on while broadcasting messages to the public is used merely as a tool to solve problems impeding his objective and in expanding his hold on the people.

Modi’s words have mostly been used to camouflage his real intent. This time too it is no different.

Two days after shepherding the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) to an astounding electoral victory, he had said ‘let bygones be bygones’. He had also said that in a nation of 1.3 billion, he, as de facto chief of the ruling party, could not "differentiate between anyone". He added the party could no longer, "differentiate on the basis caste and religion or region.

“We have shown how to achieve Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas (development for all) and now we have to win Sabka Vishwas (trust of all). We are for the people who trusted us and those whose trust we need to win.”

-PM Modi, in his speech after winning Lok Sabha polls

No Place in Cabinet for Offensive Assertions Directed at Minorities?

If people still thought he was speaking in generalities, Modi could not have been more specific: He said that after his government's focus on the poor and socially weaker sections, this time the emphasis has to be "towards winning the hearts of minorities." Taken in the backdrop of the "never will be able to forgive her" declaration in the context of Pragya Singh Thakur, this was read as a hint that people who embraced infamy with offensive assertions directed at religious minorities would find no place in his council of ministers.

Image result for maneka gandhi

While Maneka Gandhi is out for her incendiary remarks during the electoral campaign, some other forgettable leaders, Giriraj Singh (paradoxically promoted from MoS with independent charge to Cabinet rank), Niranjan Jyoti and Sanjeev Balyan have been inducted into the ministry.

Of them, while Jyoti redeemed herself after minding her tongue following the admonishment in late 2014, Balyan is back in the saddle after being sacked for a none-too-impressive performance during the previous tenure.

The reasons are obvious: Maneka Gandhi cannot deliver a caste-based vote bank to the BJP, while the others can. In fact, in their robust defense in Parliament of Jyoti in 2015, Modi and Amit Shah highlighted her being a first-time woman MP from a backward community. In the social coalition that has been fabricated under Modi, support of the non-dominant OBC and Dalit communities are essential to breach the electoral embankments of regional parties like BSP, SP and RJD.

Dilemma over Amit Shah’s Induction in Cabinet

That brings us to the big 'will he, won't he' question.

Ever since Shah took the place of Lal Krishna Advani as the party candidate from Gandhinagar, it was wondered if he would be inducted into the government to create a line of succession. If yes, the point of deliberation was his portfolio. The other bigger query was who would become BJP president.

Image result for amit shah

This issue assumed significance because the BJP has metamorphosed in the past five years into a single-minded electoral machine with the sole aim of winning polls. The organizational network has been provided heft and runs on corporate lines with clear verticals. It was argued that the huge majority notwithstanding, much remained to be accomplished.

Assembly polls are due in Maharashtra, Haryana and Jharkhand, and there is a possibility that the factors that stymied the party’s plans in the three Hindi heartland states in December last may once again bounce back – the BJP could face huge challenges on local issues and none-too-impressive performance of the state governments, especially in Haryana and Jharkhand. Additionally, there are huge challenges in Delhi and Bihar where state elections are due in 2020.

Given the BJP’s professed belief in the practice of ‘one-man, one-post’, it’s highly unlikely that Shah would continue as party chief beyond a few weeks.

BJP 2.0 As Much a Hegemon as in Modi's 1st Term

The new president (no certainty that JP Nadda would be appointed) is likely to have their hands full in regard to Bihar, as the alliance with the JD(U) appears to be following the path of the BJP's pact with the Shiv Sena immediately after the 2014 Lok Sabha elections. Back then, the two partners parted ways within months of the parliamentary elections. The BJP’s decision to contest polls separately bore fruit and it successfully wrested leadership of the alliance when the two parties reunited post polls.

A contrarian way of looking at Shah’s elevation is that by inducting him into government, Modi has effectively reduced the party president to being one among equals.

In the cabinet hierarchy, he is one notch below Rajnath Singh and although he would be member of both CCS and CPA. Whether there is any truth in this proposition or not, Modi has certainly stymied chances of the party becoming an alternate power centre.

The inability of the BJP to convince JD(U) to join the government was bad optics and underscored that impression that Modi's assertion of coalitions being important in his governance plan was mere lip-service. In fact, the BJP’s inability to convince Nitish Kumar to join the ministry establishes that the BJP is as much of a hegemon as it was in Modi's first term.

It can be deduced that the NDA remains only in name and anyone expecting regular coordination meetings to deliberate on policy matters, will be sadly mistaken.

S Jaishankar as Cabinet Minister: Bold Move That Could Raise Eyebrows

In 2014, Modi drew criticism for failing to induct urgently required talent from outside the party. In the past five years, some concessions were made and former bureaucrats and diplomats like Hardeep Puri, RK Singh and KJ Alphons were inducted into the council of ministers. The dramatic move of inducting S Jaishankar as cabinet minister – ironically, he was Puri's junior in the IFS – is both a bold move as well as one which raises eyebrows.

It’s such a bold move because Modi has inducted a professional with experience in handling the two trickiest bilateral ties – with Washington and Beijing, straddling the worlds of diplomacy and trade with the ability to pick new subjects.

Jaishankar’s initiation intopolitics could also result in a minor tempest if critics begin flagging theissue of conflict of interest, because a retired bureaucrat invariably hasdefinitive views.

Image result for s jaishankar

This will be sharply in focus if he is given charge of the foreign ministry. Often, former bureaucrats who are inducted into government are not immediately given charge of ministries they handled while in service. It may be recalled that when Rajiv Gandhi inducted K Natwar Singh in 1984, he was initially made MoS and charged with steel, coal and mines, and agriculture. External affairs were handed to him later, but only as MoS initially.

In his acceptance speech after being formally elected as leader of the NDA, Modi unveiled yet another acronym: NARA, literally a slogan for National Ambition, Regional Aspiration.

But at the end of his more than two-hour swearing-in ceremony, Modi did not have cabinet ministers to show from several states including West Bengal and Haryana. Women are also underrepresented, especially because Sushma Swaraj has dropped and Maneka Gandhi has been axed.

This shortfall and inability to induct talented women does not speak highly of Modi's gender priorities.

More Stories in News

Karsoo
230

BIMSTEC: The Strategic Neighbours Who’ll Attend Modi’s Swearing In

By Vishal Chauhan - 28/05/2019

While Narendra Modi is all set to return to power for a second term as the Prime Minister, the member nations of (BIMSTEC) have been extended invitations to the swearing in ceremony scheduled for 30 May.

Karsoo
365

Major Bollywood stars landed in the capital city Thursday for a meeting with Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

By Vishal Chauhan - 11/01/2019

The meeting comes weeks after the PM met Bollywood producers and discussed issues faced by the industry, which led to the reduction in GST on film tickets by the government.

Karsoo
345

Triple talaq bill cleared by Lok Sabha, faces big test in Rajya Sabha.

By Vishal Chauhan - 28/12/2018

The triple talaq bill seeks to criminalize the practice of instant divorce among a section of Muslims and provides for a three-year jail term for those found guilty of following the practice. The opposition had been demanding it be sent to a select committee of both houses.

Karsoo
273

‘Gave Our Blood, Soul to Jet Airways, See it Dying Now’: Employees

By Vishal Chauhan - 18/04/2019

“We gave our blood and soul to this airline and are now seeing it dying in front of our eyes. Mr Goyal said Jet is like his baby. How can someone leave a baby to strangulate to death?

Karsoo
446

Madhya Pradesh elections 2018: Will BJP be hurt by Rural Populations Anger and Corruption?

By Vishal Chauhan - 28/11/2018

The 2013 Madhya Pradesh elections were part of the poll-cycle which marked the beginning of the Modi wave. The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) got two-third majority in the state.

View More Stories