SC sets up mediation panel in Ayodhya case, gives them a month to report

Gaurav Joshi, 08/03/2019
SC sets up mediation panel in Ayodhya case, gives them a month to report

The Supreme Court on Friday ordered mediation in the Ayodhya title suit. A five-judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Ranjan Gogoi passed the order to this effect.

Mediation will start within a week at Faizabad and state of UP has to make arrangements, the Supreme Court ruled. Mediation panel has to give its report within four weeks.

The mediation will be done by a three-member panel, which the Supreme Court said, will be at liberty to induct more mediators or seek legal assistance. Justice FM Khalifulah, the retired Supreme Court judge is the chairman of the panel.

Art of Living head Sri Sri Ravi Shankar and senior advocate Sriram Panchu are the other mediators on the panel. Panchu is a trained mediator.

The top court directed both parties to maintain utmost confidentiality during the process of mediation, which will be held in-camera. There ought not to be any reporting in print or electronic of the mediation process, the court said.

The mediation panel will revert to the Supreme Court registry if there are any hurdles in the process of mediation, the five-judge bench ruled. The other judges on the bench are justices SA Bobde, DY Chandrachud, Ashok Bhushan and SA Nazeer.

The Supreme Court on Wednesday reserved its order after hearing both sides on the proposal to try out mediation as an alternative to litigation to settle the decades-old dispute.

The suggestion was opposed by the Uttar Pradesh government and the Hindu parties, except the Nirmohi Akhara, a religious denomination that is one of the main parties to the civil suit, but was welcomed by the Muslim side.

Opinion: Yet another opportunity to amicably resolve Ram temple tangle

The court is hearing petitions challenging a 2010 Allahabad high court order that trifurcated the 2.77-acre-site between the Nirmohi Akhara, the Sunni Central Waqf Board, and Ram Lalla (the child deity).

The court is also considering a petition by the Centre, which wants to release 67.7 acres of land acquired in 1993 around the site — except for .303 acres on which the actual disputed structure stood — to its original owners.

The court mentioned mediation as a possibility to resolve the contentious dispute in a hearing on February 26. The judges suggested an amicable resolution while telling the parties that they were seriously “giving a chance for mediation” in an attempt to “heal relationships”.

The verdict may assume political signifiance because it comes just weeks ahead of the general elections this summer. With the dispute having been referred to mediation, the outcome is likely be known only after the polls.

Ayodhya Case: Parties Divided as Supreme Court asks for list of mediators

Many of the Hindu parties opposed mediation saying it would only delay the case, and that previous attempts to mediate the dispute had failed.

In its last hearing on Wednesday, the judges urged lawyers on both sides to exercise restraint and not argue on history.

“Don’t tell us history. We have also read history. Do not tell us what we already know. We have no control over what happened in the past...we have no control over the past. We can only undo the present, which is the dispute before us,” Justice Bodbe said.

Justice Chandrachud, however, aired his doubts over the binding nature of mediation and whether it would work in a dispute that has taken the nature of a representative suit.

“It’s no longer a dispute between just two parties but a wider dispute between two communities. Even if we go through mediation how would it be binding on all?” he asked.

More Stories in News

Karsoo
122

Building Collapsed in Gurugram over 5 trapped.

By Vishal Chauhan - 24/01/2019

According to the agency, rescue operation to pull the people under the debris is underway. Visuals showed a bulldozer clearing debris from the site.

Karsoo
367

Bharat Band: Violence in Bihar, Gujarat, Maharashtra; public transport disrupted

By Sujit Singh - 10/09/2018

Opposition parties are today unitedly challenging the ascent in fuel costs and partaking in the across the country shutdown which was called by the Congress a week ago. Twenty other political gatherings, including the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) and the Samajwadi Party (SP), have stretched out their help to the Congress against the fuel price hike. Former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh propelled a rankling assault on the Narendra Modi government in New Delhi, where he partook in the Congress-drove across the nation dissent over rising fuel costs. In an uncommon open discourse, Singh ridiculed the Modi government for "crossing limits" and approached Opposition gatherings to join together.

Karsoo
103

Constant Struggle between the Ideal and Reality. By Osho Rajneesh.

By Vishal Chauhan - 11/02/2019

When i have to make a choice, the yes and the no are both so possible that i just don't know. What is there that i don't understand?

Karsoo
302

Microsoft surpasses Apple to becomes world’s most valuable company!

By Vishal Chauhan - 28/11/2018

Microsoft Corporation surpassed Apple Inc. to become the world’s most valuable publicly traded company. All it took was a $300 billion rout.

Karsoo
237

Hrithik Roshan Tweets that "Rakesh Roshan has early stage cancer, is in ‘full spirits’ before surgery'.

By Vishal Chauhan - 08/01/2019

Actor Hrithik Roshan has said that father Rakesh Roshan has been diagnosed with early stage throat cancer. Sharing a photo of two of them from gym, the actor said his father refused to miss workout even on surgery day.

View More Stories