The Reason Behind Justice Uday Lalit's Exit From Ayodhya Case?

Vishal Chauhan, 10/01/2019
The Reason Behind Justice Uday Lalit

The Ayodhya title dispute was deferred again today and posted to January 29 as one of the five judges in the constitution bench assigned the hear the case, Justice UU Lalit, dropped out. Justice Lalit recused himself because he had been a lawyer in a related case.

Justice Lalit appeared for former Uttar Pradesh chief minister Kalyan Singh in 1994, senior lawyer Rajeev Dhavan told the bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi. Though the lawyer said he was not seeking Justice Lalit's exit, he opted out.

Others on the bench are Justices SA Bobde, NV Ramana and DY Chandrachud.

Mr Dhawan pointed out that the case was earlier fixed for hearing before a three-judge bench but the Chief Justice took a decision to list it before a five-judge Constitution Bench. A judicial order is needed to set up a five-judge constitution bench, he argued.

Chief Justice Gogoi said "because of the facts and circumstances of the case and the voluminous records, this was a fit case for constituting a five-judge bench."

The bench said the Supreme Court registry would physically examine records stored in 50 sealed trunks. Some of the documents are in Sanskrit, Arabic, Urdu, Hindi, Persian and Gurmukhi and those need to be translated, said the judges.

The case revolves around the site in Ayodhya town where the 16th century Babri mosque stood until it was pulled down in 1992 by Hindu activists who believe it was built on the ruins of an ancient temple marking the birthplace of Lord Ram.

As many as 14 appeals have been filed in the Supreme Court against a 2010 Allahabad High Court judgement that the 2.77-acre land be partitioned equally among the three parties to the temple-mosque dispute -- the Sunni Waqf Board, the Nirmohi Akhara and Ram Lalla (infant Ram).

More Stories in News


Paytm VP Sonia Dhawan's lawyer alleges promoters were forcing her to sell stake

By Somiya Saini - 24/10/2018

Dhawan, her significant other Roopak Jain, and another Paytm representative Devendra Kumar were supposedly associated with the extorting


Sabarimala Hearing: SC Reserves Judgment on Review Petitions

By Vishal Chauhan - 06/02/2019

The Supreme Court on Wednesday, 6 February, reserved the judgment on a batch of review petition over the entry of women of all age groups in Sabarimala temple. The Travancore Dewaswom Board, which manages the temple, on Wednesday, 6 February, clarified that it supports the SC verdict allowing women of all ages to enter the shrine.


Akhilesh & Mayawati Join Hands: This Could Cost Modi Over 40 Seats.

By Vishal Chauhan - 12/01/2019

Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP) supremo Mayawati and Samajwadi Party (SP) president Akhilesh Yadav will be announcing their tie-up for the upcoming Lok Sabha elections in a press conference in Lucknow today, 12 January. There are two smaller constituents in the alliance: the Rashtriya Lok Dal and the Nishad Party. The likely seat-sharing arrangement could be the SP and BSP contesting 37 seats each, leaving three seats for the RLD and one for the Nishad Party. Uttar Pradesh has 80 Lok Sabha seats in all.


BJP Trying to Gather Votes on Masood Azhar’s Name, said Mayawati.

By Vishal Chauhan - 02/05/2019

In a huge diplomatic win for India, the United Nations on Wednesday, 1 May, designated Pakistan-based Jaish-e-Mohammed Chief Masood Azhar as a global terrorist after China lifted its hold on a proposal to blacklist him under the Security Council's Sanctions Committee. Meanwhile, reacting to the listing by the UN, Pakistan Foreign Office spokesperson was quoted as saying that it will "immediately enforce UN sanctions" imposed on Azhar.


JEE Main Result 2019

By Bhavana Sharma - 21/01/2019

It has been a week now since the conclusion of the JEE Main January session examination. What was special about the edition of the JEE Main edition was that this was conducted by National Testing Agency (NTA) for the first time. With the change in conducting body, introduction of new schemes and norms was inevitable.

View More Stories